The latest legal ruling in the Berkeley-Broad CRISPR patent battle

Do you agree with the latest legal ruling in the Berkeley-Broad CRISPR patent battle? Why or why not? If you were in charge of the CRISPR patent landscape and were not beholden to patent law, then how would you clean up the mess up of the various competing intellectual property claims? Explain. Would you rather win a patent battle or a Nobel Prize? Explain.