Critique of an article

  Region of Peel – Commodity Flow and Network Analysis. Adrian Lightstone, Mausam Duggal, (case bank: p29) Think about Abstract, strengths, opportunity or weakness and what you learn about the case, there are some questions be listed as below. Thinks about them and select 2 to 3 questions to answer for each part. (you do not need to answer all of them) Abstract An abstract is an encapsulation of the paper: • What is the paper about (scope)? • Did they identify a problem (economic, logistical, etc.) • What did the author(s) want to do (objectives)? • How did they go about doing it (methodology)? • What evidence did they use in the analysis? • What did they find (conclusion)?